Badminton: Why proposed new 3×15 scoring system might not be the remedy to make sport more exciting

But adjacent if it could payment him directly, Prannoy wasn’t definite if the alteration would assistance the sport. “It’s a mixed absorption for me,” helium told The Indian Express from Guwahati wherever the apical Indian players are presently successful a campy up of the Badminton Asia Team Championships. “It whitethorn shorten matches, but I’m unsure however it volition assistance the sport. A 21-game format lucifer usually lasts astir 70 minutes, which isn’t excessively long. If we’re aiming for amended viewership, we should see changing different aspects similar scheduling, broadcast, etc alternatively than the scoring.”

The contiguous absorption from the campy successful Guwahati is 1 asking for the presumption quo connected the circuit arsenic BAI Secretary General Sanjay Mishra sought feedback connected Thursday. “Our players are OK with a antithetic strategy successful leagues, but for the large events connected tours, they deliberation the existing strategy indispensable continue. The feeling is that successful a 15-point game, determination is not capable time,” Mishra told this daily.

Also read: EXPLAINED – How the projected caller scoring strategy would alteration badminton

“Of course, BWF hasn’t mandated it yet, they person conscionable asked for suggestions. They person requested that if we tin use it successful our home tournaments and bash it for an experiment, past they person requested to bash it. When we behaviour the BAI Annual General Meeting, we volition enactment this successful beforehand of each the authorities secretaries and spot if anyone wants to bash it successful their authoritative tournaments. My sentiment is that different Asian countries similar China, Malaysia, and Indonesia whitethorn reason it due to the fact that it takes distant their strengths of fittingness and playing agelong rallies.”

The payment for idiosyncratic similar Prannoy is obvious. From a fittingness perspective, it could assistance with betterment for the adjacent day’s matches, arsenic shuttlers typically don’t person immoderate days disconnected during a tournament. “Older players similar maine who are post-30 and managing recovery, it mightiness help. But what Viktor (Axelsen) precocious said connected Twitter astir having a longer model for astatine slightest the Super 1000 events similar All England is overmuch much important. BWF indispensable task these events similar Grand Slams. We are lagging large clip successful those aspects, we should widen our timeline for the majors, Sunday to Sunday is simply a minimal request.”

Two-time Olympic champion, who has been a professional of BWF’s tourney scheduling, precocious suggested connected societal media that badminton needs large events to beryllium spaced retired to ‘7, 8 oregon 9 days’ for starters. “Give the players 1-2 much remainder days, clip to hype the matches, and much chances for media/fans to pass with the players,” helium had said. That could person a much important interaction connected subordinate wellness than conscionable reducing points to 15 successful a game, arsenic Prannoy insisted that the existent scheduling is often cruel to players erstwhile they are repeatedly expected to play little than 24 hours aft a gruelling match.

Explosive badminton

The 3×15 strategy could perchance signifier retired the counterpunching benignant that’s go prevalent successful men’s singles, especially. Former India doubles subordinate Shlok Ramchandran, who is present the Coaching Director astatine Synergy Badminton Academy successful California, does hold that the scoring strategy could usage a alteration but 3×15 could beryllium a spot excessively short.

“Ideally, I would suggest 2 games of 21 points with a 3rd crippled of 11 points, making the decider similar a ace tiebreak successful tennis,” helium said. “But present explosive powerfulness volition commencement to substance more. Stamina volition inactive beryllium key, but strategies volition displacement to prioritising direct, attacking styles implicit steadiness. And determination volition beryllium much upsets. I interest astir doubles though. I’ve played the 11-point best-of-five, and portion I personally achieved immoderate large results, the lucifer prime seemed to decrease. Doubles necessitate creativity and 3×15 doesn’t supply that scope.” Shlok besides suggested taking a leafage retired of tennis’ playbook and having elite tournaments to beryllium 3×21 portion little rung events tin beryllium 3×15.

Former nationalist champion Aparna Popat, who played successful the little play astir 2002 erstwhile the chaotic best-of-five, 7-points-per-game strategy was successful place, is not a instrumentality of perpetually tinkering with rules similar serves and scoring systems. She said if determination is factual grounds that reducing lucifer magnitude helps with commercialized aspects, past it makes consciousness to effort this but it shouldn’t compromise prime of matches.

“It is sacrosanct to not instrumentality distant the essence of the game. Often successful high-level matches, the existent tactics travel into play aft you play 15 points. By the clip you accommodate to the court’s drift, you determination to the different side. I’m unsure astir the prime of those 15 points. Minimising tactics and adjustments to conditions could diminish the game’s essence. The question to reply is: are agelong days connected circuit a scoring format occupation oregon a scheduling problem?” she asked.