Bombay HC ruling on artistic freedom: Can young artists now be unafraid?

The practice of the nude and the bare successful Indian creation spans millennia — from the poised bronze statue of the Dancing Girl from the Indus Valley Civilisation to the graceful nudes astatine the Ajanta and Ellora caves, and the erotic sculptures astatine the temple complexes of Khajuraho — but successful much caller times their modern renderings person elicited volatile reception, extending from acts of vandalism to withdrawal of ‘contentious’ artworks from exhibitions.

In this fraught environment, the creation fraternity breathed a suspiration of alleviation erstwhile a caller Bombay High Court judgement affirmed that “every nude coating oregon each coating depicting immoderate intersexual intercourse poses cannot beryllium styled arsenic obscene.” The proceeding acrophobic 3 works by Akbar Padamsee and 4 by FN Souza, acquired successful the UK, that had been confiscated by the Customs successful Mumbai successful 2023 connected charges of being “obscene”. The Assistant Commissioner of Customs (ACC) had arguably threatened to destruct the works. Expressing that the ACC’s “impugned order” suffers from “perversity and unreasonableness”, the tribunal further noted: “The ACC failed to admit that enactment and obscenity are not ever synonymous. Obscene worldly is that which deals with enactment successful a mode appealing to prurient involvement (William J Brennan, Jr.). Such an order, successful our opinion, is unsustainable and indispensable go.”

Coincidentally, precisely 70 years ago, successful 1954, a young Padamsee was arrested from his debut solo astatine Mumbai’s Jehangir Art Gallery aft helium refused to region his paintings, Lovers I and Lovers II, which depicted a antheral and a pistillate successful the nude. He was released connected bail, and the ensuing tribunal lawsuit had arguments referencing creation history, sculptures of Khajuraho, classical Western creation and testimonies from experts specified arsenic creation connoisseur and lawyer Karl Khandalavala and German creation professional Rudolf von Leyden. Ultimately, the defiant Padamsee was acquitted of charges.

“What was objected to successful the ’50s, and deemed outrageous astatine the time, it is indefensible that the aforesaid is happening now, successful the 21st century. Once again, the courts person intervened, but the information that specified involution was indispensable speaks volumes astir the contiguous situation. In a civilization similar India, wherever we person specified a affluent contented of escaped expression, particularly successful narration to what is natural, this is profoundly troubling,” says creation historiographer and curator Yashodhara Dalmia.

****

From revered to relinquished, portraiture to erotica, the depiction of the quality assemblage successful creation has evolved implicit the centuries. Shaped by the prevailing societal, taste and humanities contexts, this narration has not lone reflected modern norms but has besides challenged established conventions.

Often considered the begetter of modern creation successful India — besides celebrated for his realistic portrayals of gods and goddesses and taking them to the masses done his oleographs — Raja Ravi Varma reportedly met absorption for his semi-nude paintings of apsaras from Indian mythology. A survey of Indian creation past would beryllium incomplete without recognising the sensual wet-sari paintings of Hemen Majumdar, MV Dhurandhar’s nudes that seamlessly blend Indian aesthetics with Western realism, the bold, avant-garde nudes of Amrita Sher-Gil and Bhupen Khakhar’s intimate exploration of homosexuality.

However, creator Balbir Krishan highlights the underlying irony wherever we are anxious to observe our wide creator past, but neglect to widen the aforesaid freedoms to artists successful modern times. “Indian civilization has agelong been wide and accepting, arsenic evidenced by the galore temples adorned with nudes and sculptures bearing intersexual overtones — artifacts we instrumentality immense pridefulness in, and rightly so. Yet, erstwhile an creator contiguous creates a nude, it faces the menace of being deemed obscene oregon condemned arsenic an battle connected our taste values. This is illogical. How tin specified accusations beryllium levelled against artists? Art is simply a signifier of expression; it embodies the dependable of the artist. The existent societal ills that request to beryllium addressed alternatively are issues specified arsenic pistillate infanticide, dowry, sex and intersexual violence, transgression against minorities, inequality and injustice,” asserts Krishan, 50. A treble amputee, his 2012 accumulation “Out Here and Now”, which celebrated homosexuality, was vandalised astatine the Lalit Kala Akademi successful Delhi, and helium was physically assaulted. In 2013, different of his exhibitions was cancelled successful Hyderabad aft the organisers received threats from vigilantes. Relocating to the US successful 2016 aft helium got married, helium shares that helium present feels freer to research a broader scope of subjects. “Artists present bask acold greater state to make and grounds immoderate they choose,” helium adds.

A young artist, who besides explores the quality assemblage done her work, recalls being cautioned that it mightiness pb to a much restricted collector-base arsenic immoderate mightiness beryllium hesitant to show the works successful their homes.

Established with the intent of coating “with implicit state for contented and technique”, respective members of the famed Progressive Artists’ Group (PAG), founded successful 1947, engaged successful explorations of the nude form. While KH Ara is known much for his classical depictions, Tyeb Mehta’s attraction of nudes was much distorted, underscoring analyzable quality emotions. Dalmia notes that Souza was profoundly moved by the affluent contented of eroticism successful past India, particularly successful Khajuraho. She states, “He felt that it was Victorian morality which had made women bashful astir their sexuality… In his nude women, we person a consciousness of women coming afloat and unashamedly into their own.”

Drawing his archetypal nude astatine the property of 16, Souza encountered censorship aboriginal on. In 1949, immoderate of his paintings, including a nude self-portrait, were seized during an accumulation astatine Art Society of India successful Mumbai connected charges of “obscenity”. Subsequently, his workplace was searched by the constabulary for pornographic material. Leaving for London wrong months, helium was to overgarment immoderate of Indian art’s astir provocative and emotionally charged nudes. Also portion of the PAG, MF Husain, too, explored nudity, including depictions of Hindu gods and goddesses and Bharat Mata, which led to aggregate tribunal cases against him for allegedly offending spiritual sentiments, culminating successful his self-imposed exile successful 2006.

*****

A signifier that had for agelong been a staple successful European creation academies since the 1800s, nude studies person been an inherent portion of the program successful world creation institutions crossed India arsenic well, but implicit the years, adjacent though the taxable has mostly continued, motivation policing has intensified scrutiny. “By the clip I retired, it was becoming comparatively harder to find models who were unfastened to posing nude for students,” says creator Vasudevan Akkitham. Having earned some his Diploma and Post-Diploma from the Faculty of Fine Arts, MS University, Baroda, Akkitham taught astatine the institute for implicit 20 years earlier retiring successful 2020.

“When we were students, we’d heard stories astir how, successful the aboriginal days of the institute, it was challenging to find models successful Baroda. They would travel from Mumbai and accommodation was specially arranged for them connected campus. However, during our time, these models were based successful Baroda. Nude studies were an important portion of the program and was assessed similar immoderate different subject.”

Addressing issues of antheral and pistillate sexuality done her art, which besides includes depictions of the nude form, octogenarian Anupam Sud reflects connected the naturalness of nudity: “It is however we are created by nature, and quality is unparalleled.” She notes that nudity is subjective, adding, “For some, adjacent a clothed assemblage tin look nude, depending connected their perspective.” Emphasising connected the value of practising nude studies and fig drawing, she says, “It is indispensable for students to recognize the intricacies of quality anatomy.”

In a state wherever superior creation acquisition is near-negligible, galore judge that deficiency of capable vulnerability besides hinders discerning knowing and mentation of art. Ashish Anand, CEO and managing manager of DAG, advocates for sensitisation programmes aimed astatine the nationalist to foster greater appreciation for art. “There is simply a deficiency of creation acquisition successful the country. Maybe this tin beryllium the catalyst for creating the consciousness that is indispensable for each modern nine — and particularly 1 which has specified a affluent and continuous reservoir of creation practices arsenic India,” states Anand.

Featuring works by immoderate of India’s astir well-regarded modernists, the gallery’s travelling exhibition, “The Naked and the Nude”, which made stops successful New Delhi, New York, and Mumbai, examined the practice of the quality assemblage successful modern India, highlighting the favoritism betwixt the bare and the nude.

In the accompanying publication, Kishore Singh, elder vice-president, DAG, wrote: “A fig whitethorn beryllium bare but it is however the oculus perceives the fig that results successful processing its nudity. It is, therefore, the creator and his intent successful portraying nakedness that whitethorn oregon whitethorn not people it arsenic nude. The oculus and its intended voyeurism — arsenic overmuch for the creator arsenic for the spectator — declares its (nude) intention… If being bare is seen arsenic a measurement of vulnerability, nudity is based connected perception.”

Anand adds: “Galleries and promoters request to instrumentality stands based connected the laws of the state and we are blessed to accidental that determination has been wide acceptance of specified views. We should not beryllium deterred by a fewer fringe elements and request to basal our ground.”

Like him, Krishan draws anticipation from the caller tribunal ruling. “In caller years, I’d go much cautious astir what I grounds successful India but the court’s unequivocal judgement is encouraging. There mightiness inactive beryllium instances wherever authorities officials oregon definite groups deem definite works offensive, but it’s reassuring to cognize that the instrumentality is connected our side.”

*name changed connected request