Critics raise concerns about Alberta being lowest in Canada for per capita spending on inmates

New information shows Alberta spends the lowest magnitude of wealth per inmate successful Canada — a fig the state says is worth for wealth but critics statement short-sighted and worrisome.

The numbers, published by Statistics Canada earlier this month, amusement Alberta spends $193 per time per inmate.

Saskatchewan spends $199.

Almost each different state and territory puts successful implicit $300.

The numbers relationship for costs similar salaries for guards and beingness necessities for inmates. They use lone to correctional centres, remand centres, radical successful custody awaiting trial, and those serving situation sentences shorter than 2 years.

The numbers are for 2022-23 and Statistics Canada, successful its online report, says inferences “should beryllium made with caution” fixed immoderate provinces whitethorn cipher their wide expenditures differently.

But erstwhile situation watchdog Howard Sapers says the Alberta spread compared with different provinces is excessively large to beryllium dismissed retired of manus arsenic conscionable accounting and infrastructure.

Sapers said it suggests Alberta is underspending connected correctional unit on with programs and supports for inmates aft they’re released.

“This is important not conscionable for those who person concerns astir what is going connected down situation walls but besides for those who are acrophobic astir nationalist safety,” Sapers, who served arsenic the Correctional Investigator of Canada from 2004 to 2016, said successful an interview.

“There is simply a narration betwixt what you put and what you get retired of it.”

Justin Piché, a University of Ottawa prof who studies incarceration, said helium believes Alberta’s comparatively debased spending level is besides a effect of the Edmonton Remand Centre — the largest jailhouse successful Canada — relying connected surveillance cameras to trim staffing costs.

“The mode that they’ve done it makes it cheaper to tally than different models that beryllium crossed the country,” Piché said.

That’s not needfully a bully thing, helium said.

“A installation that’s much bereft of quality enactment is going to beryllium much inhumane than others,” said Piché. “Human beings request quality connection, and successful these elephantine facilities there’s less opportunities for that.”

Since the Edmonton Remand Centre opened successful 2013, aggregate inquiries into inmate deaths person led judges to telephone for much staffing and face-to-face contact.

An enquiry into the 2020 termination of Jonathan Anderson led Justice Marilena Carminati to accidental successful a study past week that unless further intelligence wellness unit are hired, “similar deaths are apt to occur.”

The study says that arsenic of 2022, determination were 16 intelligence wellness workers employed astatine the remand centre, which tin clasp 1,500 inmates.

During the inquiry, an worker testified that the remand centre’s intelligence wellness portion had been short-staffed for years.

Another enquiry into an inmate termination led Justice Joyce Lester to urge successful 2022 that further officers unit the antheral intelligence wellness portion astatine each times.

Trending Now

Lawyers for the centre, successful a effect letter, rejected that suggestion, saying other staffing was not indispensable and that it “cannot warrant the portion beryllium staffed astatine each times by a minimum of 2 officers during time and day shift.”

Arthur Green, spokesperson for Alberta Public Safety Minister Mike Ellis, declined to reply an emailed question connected wherefore Alberta has the lowest regular cost.

In a statement, Green said the state is committed to the wellness and information of those successful correctional and remand centres, but “at the aforesaid time, we are liable and accountable to taxpayers.”

Green pointed to 4 correctional centres that opened therapeutic surviving units successful 2023.

“These units supply addiction attraction programs to inmates suffering from addiction and supports them successful their pursuit of recovery,” helium said.

“The intensive programming supports their intelligence wellness and ensures they tin proceed with a co-ordinated web of personalized, community-based services adjacent aft their sentences are complete.”

Green said enactment is ever evolving to rehabilitate inmates portion keeping the nationalist safe.

Piché, arsenic good arsenic Chris Hay, the president of the John Howard Society of Alberta, accidental the Alberta authorities should look astatine investing successful transgression prevention programs, arsenic good arsenic programs that assistance offenders get backmost connected their feet aft they’re released.

Hay noted that investing successful reintegration enactment is thing the Alberta authorities is starting to do, albeit slowly.

His enactment precocious received $500,000 from the state to aviator a programme astatine the Lethbridge Correctional Centre successful confederate Alberta.

The program, mirroring 1 successful Ontario, involves each inmate moving with a lawsuit manager earlier being released portion besides pairing those inmates up with non-profit organizations to entree enactment and resources aft they get out.

“It’s a measurement successful the close direction,” Hay said. “We’re starting slow, but the Alberta authorities is playing the crippled here.”

Hay said programs similar what his enactment is piloting are cardinal to reducing recidivism, which refers to the likelihood a erstwhile inmate volition proceed to perpetrate crimes upon release.

He said recidivism can’t beryllium divorced from the justness system: the much effort that goes into punishment, the higher the accidental inmates volition reoffend.

Alberta doesn’t prioritize rehabilitation, helium said.

“(It) puts a higher precedence connected enforcement and punishment.”