From EastEnders to Coronation Street, the ultimate ranking of the best soap whodunnits

We’ve reached the extremity of different ‘whodunnit’ storyline, arsenic Joel Deering’s (Calum Lill) murderer is exposed astatine past successful Coronation Street. 

In soap years, a execution enigma is simply a communicative arsenic aged arsenic time, and I couldn’t defy ranking the astir important infinitesimal successful each whodunnit – those important reveals. 

So, present are the biggest slayer unveilings successful Corrie, EastEnders, Emmerdale and Hollyoaks, from the weakest to the astir iconic. 

15. Who sabotaged the mill roof? Coronation Street (2019) 

Fan-favourite Rana Habeeb (Bhavna Limbachia) was crushed to decease successful the Underworld extortion catastrophe connected her wedding day. 

Then builder Gary Windass (Mikey North) made a voicemail confession, claiming helium deliberately damaged the extortion to get much work!  

A alternatively underwhelming outcome.  

14. Who changeable Robert Sugden? Emmerdale (2015) 

Manslaughter, manipulation and infidelity saw Robert (Ryan Hawley) timepiece up respective enemies. 

In a ‘rewind’ episode, Robert’s adoptive member Andy (Kelvin Fletcher) orchestrated his shooting to avenge woman Katie’s (Sammy Winward) death; but Ross Barton (Michael Parr) pulled the trigger connected his behalf. 

A decent wide plot, but the existent twist would person been much almighty had we seen Ross inexplicably bash the deed before the explanation. 

13. Who killed Tina McIntyre? Coronation Street (2014) 

Tina’s (Michelle Keegan) execution was teased up of transmission, earlier Rob Donovan (Marc Baylis) pushed her from a balcony and attacked her with a metallic pole. 

But stopping Tina from exposing his dodgy dealings didn’t consciousness a beardown capable motive for Rob – adjacent with his cognition of her matter with Carla’s (Alison King) hubby Peter Barlow (Chris Gascoyne). 

12. Who killed Calvin Valentine? Hollyoaks (2010) 

After a flash-forward promised his murder, Calvin (Ricky Whittle) made enemies and cheated connected woman Carmel McQueen (Gemma Merna) with her sister Mercedes (Jennifer Metcalfe) and relative Theresa (Jorgie Porter).  

Calvin ordered large Theresa to person an termination – truthful she changeable him! Dramatic arsenic ever, but successful my eyes, the daze worth doesn’t bushed Hollyoaks’ eerier offerings… 

11. Who killed Frank Foster? Coronation Street (2012) 

Frank (Andrew Lancel) escaped justness for raping Carla but ended up dormant instead. 

Sally Webster (Sally Dynevor) realised Frank’s mum Anne (Gwen Taylor) was the killer, but deed her caput earlier she could rise the alarm.  

Anne held Carla astatine knifepoint, admitting that she heard Frank goading her implicit the rape, starring to a fatal fight. Effective, but not surprising.  

10. Who killed Lucy Beale? EastEnders (2015) 

A flashback confirmed Lucy (Hetti Bywater) was accidentally killed by younger half-brother Bobby (then played by Eliot Carrington). 

In a unrecorded instalment, dada Ian (Adam Woodyatt) realised woman Jane (Laurie Brett) had covered up Bobby’s crime.  

Flanked by a beardown supporting cast, Adam’s moving, earthy portrayal acold outshone the large reveal. 

9. Who killed Emma Barton? Emmerdale (2017) 

Flashbacks intertwined with a contiguous time confession saw slayer caregiver Emma (Gillian Kearney) goading force Moira Dingle (Natalie J Robb) until Moira pushed Emma disconnected the viaduct. 

A divided 2nd determination that felt existent to character, adjacent if this twist can’t bushed what came before. 

8. Who killed Lynsey Nolan? Hollyoaks (2012) 

A flashback showed Dr Paul Browning (Joseph Thompson) strangling Lynsey (Karen Hassan) to support Mercedes.  

Simon Walker (Neil Newbon) witnessed the murder, but arsenic Lynsey had discovered his undercover constabulary operation, Walker hid and ignored her cries for help! Truly sinister. 

7. Who pushed Clare Devine? Hollyoaks (2007) 

Justin Burton (Chris Fountain) taunted Clare (Gemma Bissix) with the bombshell that helium had pushed her disconnected The Loft balcony. 

Justin had heard Clare mocking the untimely deaths of his sisters, Mel (Cassie Powney) and Sophie (Connie Powney), and took revenge.  

Clare reeled from Justin’s confession, creating different unforgettable pay-off. 

6. Who attacked Cain Dingle? Emmerdale (2012) 

Out of power Cain (Jeff Hordley) was attacked with repeated blows to the head, with dada Zak (Steve Halliwell) admitting helium was responsible.  

Their confrontation led to a soul-searching two-hander, marking 1 of the astir impactful reveals arsenic Emmerdale prioritised character-driven drama. 

5. Who is the Gloved Hand Killer? Hollyoaks (2015) 

Several villagers were bumped disconnected by a enigma medic, keeping america guessing until the past second.  

Freddie Roscoe (Charlie Clapham) survived the lethal injection – but for viewers, the effort exposed the villain arsenic his wife, Doctor Lindsey Butterfield (Sophie Austin). 

A chilling country which deserves its rightful spot connected this list. 

4. Who killed Tom King? Emmerdale (2007) 

Long earlier his namesake grandson unleashed axenic evil, Tom (Ken Farrington) was pushed done a model to his death. Sons Jimmy (Nick Miles), Matthew (Matt Healy) and Carl (Tom Lister) were main suspects. 

Carl confessed to his brothers, blaming his actions connected Tom’s controlling ways. 

This tense showdown remains 1 of Emmerdale’s finest hours, contempt Carl getting distant with the transgression for years. 

3. Who changeable Phil Mitchell? EastEnders (2001) 

Gunned down connected his ain doorstep, Phil (Steve McFadden) identified the culprit arsenic ex-girlfriend Lisa Shaw (Lucy Benjamin), who helium had abused with coercive control. 

In the days earlier societal media, their showdown was electrical viewing. 

2. The Six: Who is the flash-forward victim? EastEnders (2023) 

Turning the full premise connected its head, a flash-forward gave fans 10 months to uncover the Christmas Day unfortunate and killer.  

Linda Carter (Kellie Bright) stabbed Keanu Taylor (Danny Walters) to halt him strangling Sharon Watts (Letitia Dean).  

Linda’s interior tug of warfare earlier her deadly enactment was perfectly delivered by Kellie, making the script each the much believable. A genuine festive shocker. 

1. Who killed Archie Mitchell? EastEnders (2010) 

During a unrecorded instalment, apical fishy Bradley Branning (Charlie Clements) died aft falling from The Queen Vic roof.  

Seconds later, Bradley’s wife, Stacey (Lacey Turner) confessed rapist Archie’s (Larry Lamb) execution to ex-lover and father-in-law Max (Jake Wood).  

With conscionable 1 accidental to get it right, EastEnders pulled disconnected its most  awesome reveal, with a seamless show from Lacey that cements this twist arsenic my fig 1 choice. 

This tract is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.