Inside the minds of fans who defend the worst celebrities

Celebrity civilization has agelong been rocked by atrocious behaviour. But successful the social media age, avid fans person bigger platforms than ever to support their problematic favourites.

When it comes to ‘problematic’, determination tends to beryllium 2 camps. The archetypal are those celebrities who person faced allegations of abuse, assault, oregon transgression wrongdoing (with immoderate adjacent facing charges, though this is rare).

In caller years celebrities specified arsenic Lizzo, Johnny Depp and Louis C.K. person faced ineligible enactment owed to unsavoury accusations, though they each person since returned to the nationalist oculus oregon person plans to.

Meanwhile, nationalist figures specified arsenic P Diddy, R Kelly and Harvey Weinstein person been jailed for the severity of their crimes including enactment trafficking, and intersexual abuse.

However, being charged with a transgression is not capable to exclude you from a thriving vocation arsenic proven by President Donald Trump’s re-election (by a 75 cardinal ballot landslide) contempt being recovered liable for intersexual abuse, and Chris Brown’s continued euphony vocation aft his felony battle conviction.

On the different extremity of the spectrum are stars who person been called retired for favoritism and insensitive behaviour – whether they person been accused of targeting minorities oregon displayed shocking societal behaviour – specified arsenic Logan Paul, Dave Chappelle and JK Rowling.

The lines astir who should beryllium held accountable, and how, remains blurry depending connected the severity of the alleged transgression – and the willingness of the nationalist to forgive.

But adjacent erstwhile celebrities are formed successful their worst light, determination are inactive those who staunchly support their idols nary substance the cost.

This was possibly champion highlighted successful 2022 erstwhile Depp’s ex-wife Amber Heard accused the histrion of maltreatment and the brace went head-to-head successful a high-profile trial.

Depp had already lost a UK libel lawsuit against the Sun for calling him a wife-beater aft Heard provided grounds to backmost up the claim.

But successful the US, wherever helium sued his ex-wife for defamation, Depp won the lawsuit and  $15million (£12m) successful compensatory and punitive damage.

During this period, peculiarly connected TikTok, devoted Depp fans launched a coordinated run to blame, harass and ridicule Heard, described by the New York Times arsenic a ‘hate machine’.

Dr Ruth A Heller, Associate Professor successful Media and Communication astatine Sheffield Hallam University, told Metro that though the ‘sense of being a fan’ hasn’t changed overmuch implicit the years, the scope has acknowledgment to the internet.

She added: ‘People tin often consciousness emboldened to attack/defend idiosyncratic oregon thing erstwhile determination are others doing the aforesaid – and the net of people makes it overmuch easier to bash that.

‘That doesn’t warrant coordinated attacks, threats etc, but I don’t deliberation that’s a fandom happening per se; it happens successful effect to tons of situations.’

According to Heller, it’s successful the ‘nature of humans’ to ‘feel adjacent to idiosyncratic oregon thing that has had a immense affectional interaction connected our lives’ which tin past pb to radical ‘defending [celebrities] from onslaught and protecting them.’

We spot it reflected crossed fields whether it’s the nationalist voting for ‘politicians who person lied’ oregon purchasing from companies with ‘appalling quality rights records’.

When a dearly beloved personage is accused of wrongdoing, the affectional struggle for fans tin beryllium ‘deeply upsetting’, elder therapist Sally Baker agreed.

In the past fewer months, we person seen a immense displacement successful sentiment towards writer Neil Gaiman after helium was accused of intersexual assault, a assertion helium powerfully denies.

Large parts of his online fanbase person been vocal connected societal media astir their disappointment and determination to nary longer enactment his work, though the jarring motivation struggle is clear, arsenic shown by his Reddit leafage followed by 24,000 people.

Reddit idiosyncratic @personal_reward_60 tried to marque consciousness of the daze successful a sympathetic post, reading: ‘Your narration with the feline was parasocial archetypal and foremost truthful there’s nary mode you could person known what helium was hiding down the scenes.

‘Reserve the choler and shame for the abusers who’ve done harm. The champion happening we tin bash astatine the contiguous is amusement kindness and empathy towards the victims.’

It’s a dilemma Sally understands each excessively well.

‘Those accused of existent crimes contiguous a much clear-cut challenge. Fans whitethorn initially consciousness a consciousness of denial, struggling to reconcile the idiosyncratic they admired with the alleged transgression behaviour.

‘The cognitive dissonance tin beryllium hard to manage, and fans whitethorn spell done a grieving process arsenic they travel to presumption with the imaginable downfall of their idol.’

She continued: ‘However, fans of celebrities accused of societal missteps oregon arguable opinions whitethorn respond differently.

‘In these cases, fans whitethorn consciousness a stronger impulse to support their idol, viewing the backlash arsenic an unfair onslaught connected their idiosyncratic values oregon beliefs.’

A study by the University of Cambridge that analysed the posts from 36,464 YouTube followers of Logan Paul aft helium faced backlash for filming a dormant assemblage successful Japan’s Aokigahara forest found that radical ‘resist updating their beliefs’.

‘Imagine a personage oregon a person you greatly respect does thing you see profoundly immoral and repugnant. Would you basal by them?’ pb writer Simon Karg wrote successful the paper.

‘We tin spot that radical often support holding connected to a affirmative quality valuation adjacent erstwhile the admired idiosyncratic commits a terrible transgression.

‘The much important the idiosyncratic has been to us, the little apt we are consenting to alteration our favourable opinion.’

The survey besides noted circumstantial slang was created successful enactment of the contented creator, successful this lawsuit the operation ‘logang4life’ which is simply a improvement we person seen with different celebrities whether it is #IStandWithJKRowling oregon the aggregate anti-Amber Heard hashtags connected X.

In 2022, Forbes recovered that determination were 14,000 posts utilizing the hashtags #AmberHeardIsAnAbuser, #AmberHeardLsAnAbuser, #AmberHeardIsALiar and #AmberHeardLsALiar and 627 accounts ‘dedicated exclusively to tweeting astir Heard’.

And the #justiceforjohnnydepp saw 19 cardinal views connected TikTok, per the BBC.

As explained by Sally, the almighty operation of ‘an affectional attatchment and consciousness of identity’ tin pb much devoted fans to spot a celebrity’s downfall arsenic a ‘personal attack’.

‘The coordinated societal media campaigns, specified arsenic the 1 targeting Amber Heard, tin beryllium fuelled by the echo enclosure effect of online communities, wherever dissenting voices are often drowned retired oregon dismissed,’ she added.

This besides makes consciousness successful the lawsuit of Rowling, for whom galore fans judge her divisive, and vocal, stance connected trans women is justified.

Her past comments person compelled stars specified as Daniel Radcliffe to constitute an unfastened letter successful enactment of LGBTQ+ foundation The Trevor Project and beryllium denounced by trans charities specified arsenic Mermaids – though she denies she is transphobic.

As such, echo chambers tin pb down a unsafe road.

‘If fans are incapable to spot immoderate responsibility successful their favourite celebrities, it tin make a unsafe dynamic wherever celebrities are shielded from accountability, nary substance the severity of their actions.’

Elsewhere, Mental Health Expert Noel McDermott, pointed retired that structural inequalities play into cases similar Heard’s.

‘Attacks connected precocious illustration women are often motivated by society’s inbuilt patriarchal violence, arsenic attacks connected radical of colour are motivated by societies racism etc. There are structural societal ineqaulities astatine play,’ Noel explained.

‘There are besides radical process astatine spot successful peculiar media spaces specified arsenic the “bystander effect” wherever radical ticker maltreatment without stepping successful to debar being the 1 abused next.’

As societal media grows ever bigger, and remains a captious unit successful personage culture, what tin beryllium done to curb toxic paraoscial behaviour.

‘Celebrities themselves tin play a relation by mounting steadfast boundaries with their fanbase, being transparent astir their idiosyncratic lives and values, and actively discouraging immoderate toxic oregon obsessive behaviour,’ Sally posed.

She continued: ‘Fans should beryllium encouraged to support a steadfast region and perspective’ and that platforms and contented moderation teams had a relation to play successful mitigating ‘coordinated campaigns’.

And Noel reiterated that it was ‘crucial for our idiosyncratic improvement that we tin clasp mature feelings astir ourselves and others being some bully and atrocious astatine the aforesaid time.’

He added: ‘If we don’t bash this past we extremity up trying to dispel the ‘bad’ by projecting it outwards onto others and past effort to destruct them.’

But ultimately, this is simply a motivation dilemma that fans volition person to encouter clip and clip again fixed the fallible quality of humans.

‘The thought that “all your faves are problematic” is astir apt true, truthful we ever look those choices,’ Dr Ruth concluded.

Got a story?

If you’ve got a personage story, video oregon pictures get successful interaction with the Metro.co.uk amusement squad by emailing america celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 oregon by visiting our Submit Stuff leafage – we’d emotion to perceive from you.

MORE: Logan Paul slammed for making vile Mike Tyson menace aft Jake Paul defeat

MORE: Turns retired Tom Selleck doesn’t person the astir iconic personage moustache of all

MORE: Johnny Depp refuses to ‘carry baggage’ of Amber Heard trial