Trump’s birthright citizenship order temporarily blocked by federal judge

A national justice connected Thursday temporarily blocked President Donald Trump’s enforcement bid denying U.S. citizenship to the children of parents surviving successful the state illegally, calling it “blatantly unconstitutional” during the archetypal proceeding successful a multi-state effort challenging the order.

The 14th Amendment to the Constitution promises citizenship to those calved connected U.S. soil, a measurement ratified successful 1868 to guarantee citizenship for erstwhile slaves aft the Civil War. But successful an effort to curb unlawful immigration, Trump issued the enforcement bid conscionable aft being sworn successful for his 2nd word connected Monday.

The bid would contradict citizenship to those calved aft Feb. 19 whose parents are successful the state illegally. It besides forbids U.S. agencies from issuing immoderate papers oregon accepting immoderate authorities papers recognizing citizenship for specified children.

Trump’s bid drew contiguous ineligible challenges crossed the country, with astatine slightest 5 lawsuits being brought by 22 states and a fig of immigrants rights groups. A suit brought by Washington, Arizona, Oregon and Illinois was the archetypal to get a hearing.

“I’ve been connected the seat for implicit 4 decades. I can’t retrieve different lawsuit wherever the question presented was arsenic wide arsenic this 1 is,” U.S. District Judge John Coughenour told a Justice Department attorney. “This is simply a blatantly unconstitutional order.”

Thursday’s determination prevents the Trump medication from taking steps to instrumentality the enforcement bid for 14 days. In the meantime, the parties volition taxable further arguments astir the merits of Trump’s order. Coughenour scheduled a proceeding connected Feb. 6 to determine whether to artifact it agelong word arsenic the lawsuit proceeds.

Coughenour, 84, a Ronald Reagan appointee who was nominated to the national seat successful 1981, grilled the DOJ attorney, Brett Shumate, asking whether Shumate personally believed the bid was constitutional.

“I person trouble knowing however a subordinate of the barroom could authorities unequivocally that this is simply a law order,” helium added.

Shumate assured the justice helium did — “absolutely.” He said the arguments the Trump medication is making present person ne'er antecedently been litigated, and that determination was nary crushed to contented a 14-day impermanent restraining bid erstwhile it would expire earlier the enforcement bid takes effect.

The Department of Justice aboriginal said successful a connection that it volition “vigorously defend” the president’s enforcement order, which it said “correctly interprets the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.”

“We look guardant to presenting a afloat merits statement to the Court and to the American people, who are hopeless to spot our Nation’s laws enforced,” the section said.

The U.S. is among astir 30 countries wherever birthright citizenship — the rule of jus soli oregon “right of the soil” — is applied. Most are successful the Americas, and Canada and Mexico are among them.

The 14th Amendment was ratified successful 1868, successful the aftermath of the Civil War, to guarantee citizenship for erstwhile slaves and escaped African Americans. It states: “All persons calved oregon naturalized successful the United States and taxable to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”

Trump’s bid asserts that the children of noncitizens are not “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States, and truthful not entitled to citizenship.

Arguing for the states connected Thursday, Washington adjunct lawyer wide Lane Polozola called that “absurd,” noting that neither those who person immigrated illegally nor their children are immune from U.S. law.

“Are they not taxable to the decisions of the migration courts?” Polozola asked. “Must they not travel the instrumentality portion they are here?”

Trending Now

Polozola besides said the restraining bid was warranted because, among different reasons, the enforcement bid would instantly commencement requiring the states to walk millions to revamp wellness attraction and benefits systems to reconsider an applicant’s citizenship status.

“The enforcement bid volition interaction hundreds of thousands of citizens nationwide who volition suffer their citizenship nether this caller rule,” Polozola said. “Births cannot beryllium paused portion the tribunal considers this case.”

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown told reporters afterward helium was not amazed that Coughenour had small patience with the Justice Department’s position, considering that the Citizenship Clause arose from 1 of the darkest chapters of American law, the Supreme Court’s 1857 Dred Scott decision, which held that African Americans, whether enslaved oregon free, were not entitled to citizenship.

“Babies are being calved today, tomorrow, each day, each crossed this country, and truthful we had to enactment now,” Brown said. He added that it has been “the instrumentality of the onshore for generations, that you are an American national if you are calved connected American soil, period.”

“Nothing that the president tin bash volition alteration that,” helium said.

A cardinal lawsuit involving birthright citizenship unfolded successful 1898. The Supreme Court held that Wong Kim Ark, who was calved successful San Francisco to Chinese immigrants, was a U.S. national due to the fact that helium was calved successful the country. After a travel abroad, helium had faced being denied reentry by the national authorities connected the grounds that helium wasn’t a national nether the Chinese Exclusion Act.

But immoderate advocates of migration restrictions person argued that lawsuit intelligibly applied to children calved to parents who were some ineligible immigrants. They accidental it’s little wide whether it applies to children calved to parents surviving successful the state illegally.

Trump’s bid prompted attorneys wide to stock their idiosyncratic connections to birthright citizenship. Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, for instance, a U.S. national by birthright and the nation’s archetypal Chinese American elected lawyer general, said the suit was idiosyncratic for him. Later Thursday, helium said Coughenour made the close decision.

“There is nary morganatic ineligible statement connected this question. But the information that Trump is dormant incorrect volition not forestall him from inflicting superior harm close present connected American families similar my own,” Tong said this week.

Catalini reported from Trenton, New Jersey. Associated Press newsman Alanna Durkin Richer successful Washington, D.C., contributed to this report.