Delhi Gymkhana Club issuing green cards to those over 21 was without legal basis: HC

Green cards, akin to a licence to usage the nine facilities, are allotted to dependents of imperishable members of the Delhi Gymkhana Club connected turning 21. In March 2022, the nine had terminated greenish cards of respective individuals, forcing them to determination court.

The petitioners had contended that Articles of Association (AoA) of the nine “does not prescribe a strict deadline for submitting rank applications” and denying them the payment of greenish paper holder presumption simply owed to timing issues “would beryllium unreasonable.” The nine had contended that “green paper holders don’t suffice arsenic members of the club”.

Justice Narula, however, held: “Prima facie, the issuance of greenish cards is successful wide usurpation of the club’s AoA, lacking ceremonial authorisation oregon designation wrong its governing framework.”

“The plaintiffs’ reliance connected humanities practices and informal policies cannot substitute for compliance with the AoA, which unambiguously requires dependents to use for afloat rank upon reaching the property of 21. A strategy that circumvents this process, nevertheless longstanding, remains beyond the bounds of the club’s law framework,” the tribunal said.

It added, “The (club) administrator’s actions, including the suspension and termination of the plaintiffs’ greenish paper privileges… were portion of a indispensable inaugural to code systemic mismanagement and bring the club’s operations successful enactment with its foundational documents… The corrective measures were not punitive but remedial… designed to destruct irregularities, reconstruct organization integrity, and guarantee compliance with the AoA.”