Supreme Court delivers verdict on minority status for Aligarh Muslim University: Top quotes

Here are the apical quotes from the judgement:

📌 “The connection established arsenic utilized successful nonfiction 30(1) cannot and should not beryllium understood successful a constrictive and legalistic sense. The words utilized successful Clause 1 of Article 30 person to beryllium interpreted successful presumption of the entity and intent of the nonfiction and the warrant and extortion it confers.”

📌 “The courts indispensable place the circumstances surrounding the incorporation of the assemblage including done a speechmaking of the statute to place who established the university. Formalism indispensable springiness mode to actuality and to what is real. The close nether nonfiction 30(1) is guaranteed to minorities arsenic defined upon the commencement of the constitution.”

📌 “A antithetic close bearing radical cannot beryllium identified for institutions established earlier the adoption of the constitution. To find who established the institution, the courts indispensable see the genesis of the acquisition institution. For this analysis, the courts indispensable hint the root of the thought for the constitution of the institution.

Aligarh Muslim University field (Express Photo by Abhinav Saha)

📌 “The impervious of ideation indispensable constituent towards 1 subordinate of the number oregon the radical from the community.”

📌 “It is not indispensable that the acquisition instauration indispensable person been established lone for the payment of a spiritual oregon linguistic number community. It indispensable predominantly beryllium for its benefit. It is not indispensable that acquisition indispensable beryllium provided successful the connection spoken by the number oregon successful the religion of the minority.”

📌 “… it is not indispensable to beryllium that medication vests with a number to beryllium that it is simply a number acquisition instauration due to the fact that the precise intent of nonfiction 30(1) is to assistance peculiar rights connected medication arsenic a effect of establishment. To bash otherwise, would magnitude to converting the effect to a precondition.”

📌 “An instauration to beryllium a number instauration indispensable fulfill the criteria of being administered arsenic a number instauration connected the day of the commencement of the constitution and being a number instauration connected the day of formation.”

📌 “Even if an acquisition instauration was established by the number for the intent of the community, we indispensable measure the interaction of immoderate consequent events that change the quality of the instauration earlier the commencement of the constitution.”