As the results for the Delhi Assembly elections poured in, I was reminded of a remark by the precocious Sushma Swaraj, the past BJP Chief Minister of Delhi. With the votes being counted successful November 1998 astatine the highest of the bulb terms crisis, it became wide that the BJP was connected its mode out. Swaraj said, “Ghar ko aag lag gayee ghar ke chirag se (The location was burnt down by a lamp wrong the house).” She was referring to the quarrels betwixt assorted factions of the BJP, chiefly with her contiguous predecessor, Sahib Singh Verma. Ironically enough, it is the latter’s lad who has defeated Arvind Kejriwal today, and the BJP is connected its mode backmost to powerfulness successful Delhi.
The BJP has polled a small implicit 45 per cent of the votes, which is conscionable astir 2 percent points much than the AAP. Congress, with conscionable implicit 6 per cent of the votes, has emerged arsenic the existent spoiler successful the election.
Story continues beneath this ad
Much similar the 4 Ps of marketing, arsenic formulated by Philip Kotler, electoral success, too, has 4 Ps — problem-solving, perception, enactment apparatus and adjacent leadership. In the eyes of the voter, problem-solving is the cardinal to electoral sustenance. A elector consistently looks for solutions that tin amended his oregon her prime of living. So, portion immoderate problems whitethorn person been solved, determination are others that voters registry arsenic intractable, oregon wherever nary oregon small headway is possible. In specified cases, they either thin to presume each parties to beryllium arsenic culpable, oregon springiness the payment of the uncertainty to the Opposition.
Riding connected the committedness of anti-corruption, the AAP had built its individuality connected municipality governance successful its earlier terms. Clearly, however, connected issues similar contamination and the prime of drinking water, the enactment was astir arsenic clueless arsenic anyone else. This near elbow country for its opponents. The AAP had been voted to powerfulness connected the presumption that it was a problem-solver; the infinitesimal it was stopped abbreviated by definite intractable issues, it was assumed to person mislaid its borderline connected 1 of the 4 Ps.
Problem-solving has to beryllium cardinal to a governmental machine, which can’t conscionable trust connected cognition and enactment apparatus. While the AAP could lucifer the BJP connected perception, the second has scored implicit the AAP with its enactment apparatus. It was besides capable to marque Kejriwal retired arsenic 1 without adjacent enactment qualities, with the AAP being a single-leader party. That, successful a nutshell, explains the last result of the election.
Story continues beneath this ad
The AAP is much oregon little down to the footprint it had successful its debut predetermination successful 2013, confined to the cardinal and eastbound parts of Delhi. On the different hand, the fielding of Parvesh Verma against Kejriwal was a awesome to Jats who, till the Haryana elections, were considered to beryllium acold to the BJP. The BJP has made a cleanable sweep of occidental and northwestern Delhi, and ample pockets of confederate Delhi, wherever they are game-changers
Another conception that the BJP has won backmost is middle-class voters. That was a important chunk which had walked distant from the BJP implicit the past 2 assembly elections, enamoured by Kejriwal’s committedness of a cleaner politics. The South Delhi seats unsocial archer a story. Of the 15 seats here, the AAP has won lone a fistful of the 14 seats it had won past time. If the AAP had lone managed to repetition its earlier occurrence here, it would person managed to travel wrong striking region of power. The wide plaything successful favour of the BJP being 7 per cent tells the story, wherever a important tax-paying people has made each the difference. But then, what happened to the people that was to ballot for AAP due to the fact that of the freebies they received? There excessively acquisition teaches america that unless determination is simply a accordant betterment successful the prime of life, the voters don’t instrumentality around.
This is precisely the quandary that the determination parties successful Tamil Nadu face. The Dravidian parties vie successful dishing retired each kinds of freebies, from mixer-grinders and colour TV sets to post-pregnancy kits. And, yet they person to alternate successful power. The precocious J Jayalalithaa was capable to bushed anti-incumbency narrowly lone erstwhile successful 2016, which was her past election. Conversely, contempt immoderate of the worst accusations of corruption, some parties person managed to claw backmost power, arsenic the voters person either discarded the astir intractable problems from their intelligence to-do lists, oregon person held some to beryllium arsenic liable for leaving them unsolved.
Moreover, the vagaries of the first-past-the-post exemplary often change mandates astatine the spot level, wherever constrictive margins tin plaything elections towards astonishing results. The results to the Odisha Assembly successful 2024 connection a classical example: The Biju Janata Dal had an uninterrupted tally for astir 25 years, and adjacent successful its decision its vote-share was a tad higher than the BJP’s. In Delhi, arsenic of now, the vote-share quality betwixt the BJP and AAP is narrow, indicating that the second is not wholly retired of the race.
Going ahead, the AAP volition request to look for a caller USP. Unlike the BJP, which has a accordant communicative and a threshold quantum of voters that are aligned to it, for the AAP the travel has conscionable begun. It’s a agelong roadworthy up to found a robust, ideologically committed cadre similar the BJP has. The BJP, connected the different hand, present has the situation of presenting itself arsenic a enactment of municipality governance, and showing that it tin outdo AAP. It besides has the situation of consolidating middle-class voters nationwide to support with itself a sliver of voters who tin mean the quality betwixt the treasury benches and the Opposition.
The writer is simply a governmental commentator and psephologist