Will Santa Ana Officials Minimize Photographer Restrictions at City Hall?

Santa Ana officials are considering adjusting a argumentation that restricts wherever photojournalists tin instrumentality pictures during nationalist meetings astatine metropolis hallway aft pushback from writer organizations and a salient First Amendment rights group.

It’s besides a regularisation Voice of OC’s Publisher and Editor successful Chief Norberto Santana Jr. criticized successful a caller column, instituting a argumentation protesting the photograph restrictions by moving a cartoon depiction of assembly meetings. 

[Read: Santana: Politicians successful Santa Ana Don’t Want Residents To See Them Up Close]

On Monday during a continued metropolis assembly gathering from past week, assembly members directed unit to travel backmost with changes to the media argumentation to marque it much flexible depending connected however crowded the assembly chambers are during meetings.

Councilwoman Thai Viet Phan, who called for a much flexible policy, said astatine Monday’s gathering that it is communal to person property zones to guarantee exigency unit similar constabulary officers tin person wide entree passim the room.

“We tin person thing that’s a small spot much flexible and doable depending connected the situation,” she said.

Yet successful caller years, Voice of OC photojournalists person lone been confined to a definite abstraction successful 1 different spot erstwhile the Orange Unified School District committee gathering was packed past year. 

Councilman David Penaloza agreed with Phan, saying determination needs to beryllium a equilibrium and that helium has nary occupation with reporters trying to seizure photos successful the beforehand aisles erstwhile the chambers are not packed.

“When determination are packed chambers similar we’ve seen successful the past, lasting successful beforehand of idiosyncratic that’s seated successful a wheelchair – similar we’ve seen earlier – that’s conscionable plain rude,” helium said.

Penaloza besides said helium wants to marque meetings comfy for residents to talk their mind. 

“We privation to marque it a comfy abstraction for everybody that’s exercising their First Amendment close to travel and talk and if it’s a packed chamber, packed room, yeah, they should beryllium designated areas for the property to bent retired in,” helium said astir the policy.

The California First Amendment Coalition is calling connected officials to rescind the media policy, arguing it goes against authorities law.

Last week, David Loy, the coalition’s ineligible director, told the Voice of OC the Brown Act – California’s unfastened gathering instrumentality – guarantees journalists the close to grounds a metropolis assembly gathering arsenic agelong arsenic determination is nary persistent disruption to the meeting.

[Read: Will Santa Ana Officials Lift Restrictions connected Photojournalists astatine Public Meetings?]

Ginny LaRoe, advocacy manager with the First Amendment Coalition, sent a missive to metropolis assembly members demanding they retreat the argumentation – citing reporting by the Voice of OC.

“Given the Brown Act gives the metropolis assembly indispensable tools for taking enactment against a person

who causes a persistent disruption, and fixed the First Amendment’s protections against

discriminating against members of the property who whitethorn astatine times photograph oregon grounds meetings, the metropolis should instantly determination guardant with abandoning its policy,” reads LaRoe’s Sept. 17 letter.

City Attorney Sonia Carvalho said the existent argumentation complies with authorities law.

“I’m besides precise respectful of a assembly that wants flexibility and wants to beryllium capable to beryllium responsive to immoderate of the comments you received,” she said astatine Monday’s meeting.

Councilman Phil Bacerra besides supported revisions and called Santa Ana the astir “transparent” metropolis successful OC.

“There are folks that are capable to ticker this gathering astatine location connected YouTube, capable to enactment via Zoom. We were doing that during the pandemic, erstwhile a batch of different cities weren’t,” helium said, adding that a elder exertion astatine the OC Register besides called connected officials to revise the policy.

In OC’s largest city, Mayor Ashleigh Aitken declared Anaheim the astir transparent successful OC pursuing a host of reforms successful the aftermath of a corruption scandal. 

Over there, Voice of OC journalists haven’t been placed successful definite areas of a country to study and instrumentality pictures from – adjacent successful the aftermath of the ungraded erstwhile the assembly chambers were packed. 

However, the metropolis does not let residents to marque nationalist comments implicit Zoom and lone recently started streaming unrecorded meetings connected YouTube.

Santa Ana Councilwoman Jessie Lopez, who on with Councilman Benjamin Vazquez, unsuccessfully pushed to nix the policy, said unit should guarantee the revised argumentation doesn’t interruption the Brown Act and is vetted by metropolis lawyers.

“We don’t person to similar the press. We don’t person to similar what they write. But we person to respect them due to the fact that they’re an important constituent of our democracy, and they bash large reporting,” Lopez said.

Credit: Carlos Conde

The argumentation was revised earlier by removing a section that explicitly prohibits filming, photography and signaling “in aisles, successful beforehand of the dais, successful beforehand of doors/entrances/emergency exits, and astatine immoderate different locations that whitethorn impede the question of gathering attendees.”

The existent argumentation inactive requires photographers utilizing ample instrumentality similar tripods to instrumentality pictures from designated areas.

In the past, metropolis spokesperson Paul Eakins defended the media argumentation and his petition to a Voice of OC lensman to determination to a rear media conception to instrumentality pictures.

“Our extremity astatine City of Santa Ana nationalist meetings is ever to support transparency, nationalist and media access, and compliance with the First Amendment and the Brown Act,” Eakins said successful a erstwhile email.

“But we besides indispensable guarantee that aisles, exigency exits and nationalist entree points stay wide for some members of the nationalist and nationalist information personnel.”

Eakins himself has taken pictures of radical during assembly presentations successful an aisle successful beforehand of the dais.

He said successful an email past week that helium lone takes a little infinitesimal to instrumentality the photograph and journalists not utilizing ample instrumentality tin beryllium anyplace successful the assembly chambers.

“This is little and not during a clip erstwhile doing truthful would artifact the public’s presumption of the Council deliberations, votes, presentations, etc., nor are individuals blocking the aisles oregon doorways. I besides don’t usage oregon spot tripods successful the aisles for this, which again is the superior intent of the media guidelines successful bid to support these areas clear,” helium wrote.

The revisions to the media argumentation is expected to travel backmost for a ballot successful 30 days.

Phan publically asked if metropolis unit could exert flexibility successful enforcing the argumentation successful the meantime.

Mayor Valerie Amezcua and City Manager Alvaro Nuñez pushed backmost connected the idea, saying it would beryllium hard to instrumentality fairly.

“We privation to beryllium consistent,” Nuñez said.  “We privation to beryllium fair.”

Julie Leopo contributed to the reporting successful this article.

Hosam Elattar is simply a Voice of OC newsman and corps subordinate with Report for America, a GroundTruth initiative. Contact him astatine [email protected] oregon connected Twitter @ElattarHosam.

•••